Social Media and Young Australians: Is a Blanket Ban the Right Approach?

The Australian government’s move to ban social media access for children under 16 has sparked a nationwide debate. With strong opinions on both sides, this legislation—hailed as a world-first—raises critical questions about child safety, digital rights and the broader implications of online regulation. The conversation is anything but straightforward.

The Case for the Ban

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has positioned the legislation as a measure to protect young Australians from the harms of social media, such as cyberbullying, mental health decline and exposure to harmful content. Supporters, including advocacy groups like Heads Up Alliance, argue that this is a long-overdue step toward reclaiming childhood from the grasp of addictive digital platforms. A YouGov poll conducted in October 2023 found that between 68% and 77% of Australians support the ban, reflecting a public concern that transcends political divides.

% of Australians who support or oppose each (excluding don't know)

Some experts, such as Professor Sonia Livingston, who specialises in children's digital experiences, believe social media exacerbates anxiety, depression and body image issues in teenagers. The rapid spread of harmful trends and online shaming have made platforms like Instagram and TikTok minefields for young users. The argument is clear: removing children from these spaces could alleviate significant psychological burdens.

The Debate Over the Ban

However, many believe that while the concerns are valid, the solution is flawed. A group of 40 academics recently signed an open letter to Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, arguing that the ban is “too blunt an instrument” to address the issue effectively. They stress that social media plays a role in fostering community, especially for marginalised groups. Removing children from online spaces doesn’t eliminate harmful content; it merely pushes these interactions elsewhere, such as gaming platforms like Roblox, which also include social features.

There’s also skepticism about enforcement. Will age verification require children—and potentially all users—to provide government-issued ID? If so, privacy advocates fear this could set a precedent for broader digital surveillance. Critics argue that instead of banning access, the government should focus on holding social media companies accountable for harmful content and algorithmic manipulation.

The Rush to Legislate

One of the most significant concerns raised is the speed at which this law was pushed through parliament. Some argue that the rushed process was motivated more by political optics than by a thorough consideration of its consequences. While the law will not take effect for another 12 months, many question whether this period will be sufficient for developing an effective enforcement mechanism.

Meta, TikTok and Snapchat have all voiced concerns that they were not given adequate time to consult or prepare for compliance. This raises an essential question: Should the responsibility of enforcement fall on tech companies, or should the government take the lead in ensuring effective implementation?

The Real Issue: Addressing the Root Causes

A key takeaway from discussions is the need to examine why young people are so drawn to social media. Is it a response to loneliness, boredom, or pressure? Simply restricting access does not address the underlying issues that drive young people online in the first place.

As PJ Vogt put it, “You can try to turn off the machine, or regulate it towards being less addictive. But you might also try to understand why the void it's promising to attend to is there in the first place”. Without investing in offline alternatives—such as community programs, youth centres and mental health initiatives—this policy may simply push young people towards riskier, unregulated digital spaces.

The Global Implications

Australia’s decision is being closely watched worldwide, with some viewing it as a template for future legislation. Figures like Elon Musk have framed the move as an attempt at government overreach and internet control, while others see it as a necessary first step in addressing a growing digital crisis, while others see it as a necessary first step in addressing a growing digital crisis. The UK has already explored similar measures with its Online Safety Bill, though enforcement has proven complex.

A Work in Progress

At its core, the ban reflects an effort to address very real concerns about social media’s impact on young people. However, as the conversation unfolds, it’s clear that a one-size-fits-all approach is unlikely to yield the best results. The government now faces a critical period where it must refine the law’s implementation and address public concerns around privacy, enforcement and unintended consequences.

The question remains: Is this ban a groundbreaking move to protect young Australians, or is it an oversimplified solution to a deeply complex issue? Only time will tell.

---

Further Resources

For those interested in exploring this topic further, here are some helpful resources:

• Government of Australia: Social Media Regulation Overview – Official information on the legislative measures regarding social media restrictions for minors. Read more here

• YouGov Poll on Public Support for Social Media Ban – A survey highlighting Australian public opinion on social media restrictions for children under 16. View the poll results here

• Open Letter from Academics on Social Media Ban – A critique of the legislation by 40 academics, arguing against the ban as an overly simplistic solution. Read the open letter here

• Australian Human Rights Commission – An official response from the Commission highlighting concerns over the legislation and its potential human rights implications. Visit here

• Search Engine Podcast Episode – A deep dive into how students are using AI and the evolving debate in education. Listen to the episode here.

• UK Online Safety Bill: Lessons for Australia – A comparative analysis of similar legislation in the UK and its implications for Australia. Learn more here

• Everything is Content Podcast – A discussion on the broader impacts of Australia's social media ban, featuring expert opinions and public reactions. Listen here

• Big Small Talk Podcast – Insights into the political and societal effects of banning social media for minors in Australia. Tune in here